Difference between revisions of "Understanding Masturbation"
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
'''This page needs a lot of work.''' | '''This page needs a lot of work.''' | ||
| − | == | + | == Presenting the Issur to Boys == |
| − | + | The emission of zera not in the context of marriage is called hotza’as zera l’vatala (to waste, since it is not for its intended purpose). | |
| − | + | The Torah has instructed us that until the special context of marriage we are to try our best to avoid histaklus or hirhurim (intentional thoughts) about sexual matters. That includes any material that can bring to such things such as not-tznius stories, pictures, or videos. Similarly, it is not appropriate to discuss, joke about, or engage in any activities that can sexually excite a | |
| − | + | person, even if zera does not come out. Also, we are instructed to avoid anything that may lead to zera coming out, such as touching the penis more than necessary, let alone specifically trying to excite it. The secular world calls intentionally stimulating one’s genitals masturbation. Despite what you may hear, physically or medically there is no harm in causing the zera to come out, | |
| − | + | However, as we said, the Torah prohibits it.<ref>From an unpublished draft of a book for parents that GYE is working on.</ref> | |
| − | === | + | == Notes == |
| − | |||
| − | + | * Teshuva is possible, see [[Teshuva]]. | |
| − | + | == Understanding the Words of Chazal == | |
| − | + | === Approach 1 === | |
| + | Most of those who have been nichshal have already seen the dark picture that is painted in many sefarim for someone who slipped in this area. This creates a tremendous amount of guilt and hopelessness. Quite often these feelings do more harm than good. The person gets upset by what he sees written in sefarim and then continues to act out and becomes more upset. It is therefore imperative for any person struggling with this nisayon to gain a proper understanding into the words of Chazal on this topic.<ref>עי’ בקריינא אגרתא, ח”א אגרת קי"ב, שביאר מש”כ בספרים אודות הנכשל בחטא זה; ועי’ עוד בפי’ מתנת חלקו מהגה”צ ר’ מתתיהו סלומון שליט”א על שערי תשובה, שער שלישי אות קז.</ref> | ||
| − | + | The main idea that must be conveyed is that not everything written in sefarim was intended for every person at every time. A person needs to have a Rebbi who tells him what Chazal meant and who they were addressing. If a bachur has a hard time accepting this, it can be pointed out to him that even within the words of Chazal, there seem to be various contradictions. There are some ma’amarei Chazal that give hope and chizuk, while others discuss the negativity and punishments. | |
| − | + | Obviously there are no real contradictions in Chazal, and all of their words are true. However, the point being made here is that just as one needs a Rebbi to teach him how to understand a sugya in Shas, so, too, must one have a Rebbi to understand this sugya in hashkafah. Additionally, it’s important to emphasize that anything written in sefarim pertaining to this topic was done with one intention in mind: to get a person to stop his bad behaviors. If a bachur sees that he’s acting out more after learning from a specific sefer, or he is falling into a deeper depression, then he is obviously coming away with a message contrary to the purpose for which the sefer was written. If he then asks you what the correct understanding is, you can offer to sit down and figure out the pshat together. However, you should stress to him that whatever the pshat might be, it’s not the one that he had in mind, the proof being that his understanding is leading him in the wrong direction.<ref>''Oizer Bigevura p. 58.''</ref> | |
| + | |||
| + | == Effects of Masturbation == | ||
| + | If a bochur asks what's the big deal, here are some things that can be shared with them: | ||
| + | |||
| + | * It is a lonely and selfish action. Hashem created this drive for the purpose of a husband and wife connecting, giving to each other, and potentially creating another life, a selfless act on so many levels. Masturbation is a corruption of the essence of the proper and intended purpose for this drive. Engaging in masturbation conditions a person to see the expression of this drive as a selfish act and can reduce the happiness one can experience in marriage. In addition, marriage benefits greatly from being exclusive (the language of “''kedushin''” indicates this as well)... Even experiences in these areas of kedusha with oneself, as a selfish act, take away from the specialness of these experiences being exclusive to marriage.<ref>[http://wiki.guardyoureyes.com/Maintaining%20Kedusha ''Maintaining Kedusha'']</ref> | ||
| + | * It should be considered that due to the strength of this drive, it is easier for an addiction to form. Sometimes bochurim might use masturbation as an escape from a particular stress or issue in their life or psyche.<ref>[http://wiki.guardyoureyes.com/Maintaining%20Kedusha ''Maintaining Kedusha'']</ref> | ||
| + | |||
| + | == Torah Sources == | ||
| + | |||
| + | * Shulchan Aruch, Even Haezer Siman 23<ref>Some bochurim might get tremendous chizuk from going through the Shulchan Aruch – Even Haezer Siman 23. Seeing how the Torah and Chazal deal with this ''tayva'' as real, and powerful, can be validating and normalizing for a bochur. Additionally, there are multiple ''halachos'' there detailing with how to be careful. These ''halachos'' can be enlightening and helpful for the bochur working on self-control in this area. - R' Avi Landa, in ''Maintaining Kedusha.''</ref> | ||
Revision as of 11:22, 12 November 2020
This page needs a lot of work.
Presenting the Issur to Boys
The emission of zera not in the context of marriage is called hotza’as zera l’vatala (to waste, since it is not for its intended purpose).
The Torah has instructed us that until the special context of marriage we are to try our best to avoid histaklus or hirhurim (intentional thoughts) about sexual matters. That includes any material that can bring to such things such as not-tznius stories, pictures, or videos. Similarly, it is not appropriate to discuss, joke about, or engage in any activities that can sexually excite a
person, even if zera does not come out. Also, we are instructed to avoid anything that may lead to zera coming out, such as touching the penis more than necessary, let alone specifically trying to excite it. The secular world calls intentionally stimulating one’s genitals masturbation. Despite what you may hear, physically or medically there is no harm in causing the zera to come out,
However, as we said, the Torah prohibits it.[1]
Notes
- Teshuva is possible, see Teshuva.
Understanding the Words of Chazal
Approach 1
Most of those who have been nichshal have already seen the dark picture that is painted in many sefarim for someone who slipped in this area. This creates a tremendous amount of guilt and hopelessness. Quite often these feelings do more harm than good. The person gets upset by what he sees written in sefarim and then continues to act out and becomes more upset. It is therefore imperative for any person struggling with this nisayon to gain a proper understanding into the words of Chazal on this topic.[2]
The main idea that must be conveyed is that not everything written in sefarim was intended for every person at every time. A person needs to have a Rebbi who tells him what Chazal meant and who they were addressing. If a bachur has a hard time accepting this, it can be pointed out to him that even within the words of Chazal, there seem to be various contradictions. There are some ma’amarei Chazal that give hope and chizuk, while others discuss the negativity and punishments.
Obviously there are no real contradictions in Chazal, and all of their words are true. However, the point being made here is that just as one needs a Rebbi to teach him how to understand a sugya in Shas, so, too, must one have a Rebbi to understand this sugya in hashkafah. Additionally, it’s important to emphasize that anything written in sefarim pertaining to this topic was done with one intention in mind: to get a person to stop his bad behaviors. If a bachur sees that he’s acting out more after learning from a specific sefer, or he is falling into a deeper depression, then he is obviously coming away with a message contrary to the purpose for which the sefer was written. If he then asks you what the correct understanding is, you can offer to sit down and figure out the pshat together. However, you should stress to him that whatever the pshat might be, it’s not the one that he had in mind, the proof being that his understanding is leading him in the wrong direction.[3]
Effects of Masturbation
If a bochur asks what's the big deal, here are some things that can be shared with them:
- It is a lonely and selfish action. Hashem created this drive for the purpose of a husband and wife connecting, giving to each other, and potentially creating another life, a selfless act on so many levels. Masturbation is a corruption of the essence of the proper and intended purpose for this drive. Engaging in masturbation conditions a person to see the expression of this drive as a selfish act and can reduce the happiness one can experience in marriage. In addition, marriage benefits greatly from being exclusive (the language of “kedushin” indicates this as well)... Even experiences in these areas of kedusha with oneself, as a selfish act, take away from the specialness of these experiences being exclusive to marriage.[4]
- It should be considered that due to the strength of this drive, it is easier for an addiction to form. Sometimes bochurim might use masturbation as an escape from a particular stress or issue in their life or psyche.[5]
Torah Sources
- Shulchan Aruch, Even Haezer Siman 23[6]
- ↑ From an unpublished draft of a book for parents that GYE is working on.
- ↑ עי’ בקריינא אגרתא, ח”א אגרת קי"ב, שביאר מש”כ בספרים אודות הנכשל בחטא זה; ועי’ עוד בפי’ מתנת חלקו מהגה”צ ר’ מתתיהו סלומון שליט”א על שערי תשובה, שער שלישי אות קז.
- ↑ Oizer Bigevura p. 58.
- ↑ Maintaining Kedusha
- ↑ Maintaining Kedusha
- ↑ Some bochurim might get tremendous chizuk from going through the Shulchan Aruch – Even Haezer Siman 23. Seeing how the Torah and Chazal deal with this tayva as real, and powerful, can be validating and normalizing for a bochur. Additionally, there are multiple halachos there detailing with how to be careful. These halachos can be enlightening and helpful for the bochur working on self-control in this area. - R' Avi Landa, in Maintaining Kedusha.